TL;DR
Large language model responses are often slow, so a developer built popup-mcp: a local tool that lets LLMs spawn structured, conditional GUI elements (checkboxes, dropdowns, sliders, textboxes) to capture multi-step input. That approach preserves semantic power while cutting average user-perceived latency by amortizing a single expensive LLM call over many fast local interactions.
What happened
A developer writing at Tidepool Heavy Industries argues that natural language chat alone is not always the best interface for every interaction because LLM inference typically takes tens of seconds. To address this, they built popup-mcp, a local MCP (tool-use) utility that runs over stdio and spawns popups composed of GUI widgets—multiple-choice, dropdowns, sliders and textboxes—that an LLM can generate on demand. Those popups support conditionally visible elements so follow-up questions appear only when triggered by prior answers, and every multiselect or dropdown automatically includes an "Other" option that reveals a freeform textbox. Answers collected in the popup are returned to the LLM as JSON. The author reports this pattern can reduce amortized interaction latency by roughly 25–75% compared with raw conversational turns and compares it to Claude Code’s AskUser TUI, noting differences and proposed feature enhancements for that tool.
Why it matters
- Reduces perceived wait time by shifting many small interactions to instant, local GUI updates while keeping LLM reasoning for higher-level steps.
- Combines fast deterministic affordances of GUIs with the semantic flexibility of LLMs, improving efficiency for multi-field tasks.
- Conditional elements and an "Other" escape hatch surface the LLM’s intended follow-ups and let users correct misassumptions without long back-and-forths.
- The pattern can be applied across terminal, web and OS-native interfaces, making it broadly applicable to LLM-enabled apps.
Key facts
- The author built popup-mcp about six months before the post was published.
- Popup-mcp is a local MCP tool that communicates over stdio, so it must run on the same machine as the LLM client.
- Supported UI elements include multiple-choice checkboxes, dropdowns, sliders and textboxes.
- Elements support conditional visibility so follow-up questions can appear only when specific conditions are met.
- All multiselects and dropdowns automatically include an "Other" option that reveals a textbox for user input.
- Answers from the popup are returned to the LLM as a JSON-formatted tool response.
- The author reports an amortized latency reduction of roughly 25–75%, depending on how well the LLM anticipates the conversation.
- The post compares the approach to Claude Code’s AskUser tool, noting AskUser provides a limited TUI and suggesting feature improvements.
What to watch next
- The author says they will publish more work and follow-up posts; watch for future updates.
- Whether LLM chat applications adopt inline structured GUIs with conditional follow-ups is not confirmed in the source.
- Whether Anthropic implements the author’s suggested AskUser extensions (scriptability, hooks, conditional elements) is not confirmed in the source.
Quick glossary
- LLM: Large language model — a machine learning model trained to generate or understand text, often used for conversational or generative tasks.
- GUI: Graphical user interface — visual elements like buttons, dropdowns and sliders that let users interact with software quickly and deterministically.
- MCP: A standardized tool-use interface for LLMs (as used by the author) that lets models invoke external helper tools.
- Amortized latency: The effective average latency per user interaction when an expensive operation (like an LLM call) is spread over multiple fast local interactions.
- Conditional visibility: UI elements that remain hidden until specific conditions in the user’s inputs are met, enabling context-sensitive follow-up prompts.
Reader FAQ
Is popup-mcp publicly available?
The author says popup is available alongside instructions, but a download link or repository details are not reproduced in the source.
Does popup-mcp run remotely or locally?
It is a local MCP tool using stdio, so the process needs to run on the same computer as the LLM client.
Will this eliminate LLM latency entirely?
No. The approach reduces amortized interaction latency by allowing many quick local interactions, but full LLM responses still take tens of seconds.
Is Claude’s AskUser already the same as popup-mcp?
AskUser provides limited terminal UI elements and inspired part of the comparison, but popup-mcp adds conditional elements and other differences highlighted by the author.
Tidepool Heavy Industries Stop using natural language interfaces Natural language is a wonderful interface, but just because we suddenly can doesn't mean we always should. hikikomorphism January 13, 2026 4…
Sources
- Stop using natural language interfaces
- A Multimodal GUI Architecture for Interfacing with LLM …
- Rethinking LLM interfaces, from chatbots to contextual …
- Real-time GUIs customization with large language models
Related posts
- Gleam: A Typed Functional Language on the Erlang (BEAM) Runtime
- Open-source AI agent that indexes and searches Epstein files archive
- Axis: a minimalist systems programming language with Python syntax